mcall at SUPERAJE.COM
Sat Apr 18 07:49:15 CDT 1998
Hybridisation per se does not indicate that the two entities are conspecific.
Hybrids can be sterile. Hybridisation with fertile offspring can be so rare
that there is no significant genetic interchange between the two species which
are thus able to maintain their distinctions. Hybridisation may occur when the
environment is severely disturbed by humans or where the numbers of one species
are so depleted by humans that there is little opportunity to find a mate of
the same species, but be absent in undisturbed areas. About 1% of the sucker
family, Catostomidae (a fish family) are saide to be hybrids in the U.S., but
the species remain distinct.
Curtis Clark wrote:
> At 11:53 AM 4/17/98 +0000, ROGER HYAM wrote:
> >If a cross occures between sister taxa then it suggests that these
> >taxa should be considered as a single entity - how could we show that
> >these two taxa (OTUs in our analysis) aren't segregates of a larger
> >taxon? 'Hybrids' of this type should not be formally recognised.
> Even if the hybrids are sterile?
> And consider the following case:
> B--+ +----
> By your measure, a hybrid between A and B would demonstrate that they are
> conspecific, but a hybrid between A and C, since they are not sister taxa,
> would be a hybrid. But if A and B are conspecific, then C is the sister to
> the species A+B, so A x C is not a hybrid. Following this method, one could
> reduce much of the Orchidaceae to synonymy.
> Curtis Clark http://www.intranet.csupomona.edu/~jcclark/
> Biological Sciences Department Voice: (909) 869-4062
> California State Polytechnic University FAX: (909) 869-4078
> Pomona CA 91768-4032 USA jcclark at csupomona.edu
Don E. McAllister /& Canadian Centre for Biodiversity
Ocean Voice International /Canadian Museum of Nature
Box 37026, 3332 McCarthy Rd. /Box 3443, Station D
Ottawa, ON K1V 0W0, Canada /Ottawa, ON K1P 6P4
URL: http://www.ovi.ca E-mail: mcall at superaje.com
(or: ah194 at freenet.carleton.ca) Tel: (613) 264-8986, Fax: (613) 264-9204
More information about the Taxacom