Student's perspective

Mon Oct 11 18:18:55 CDT 1999

Dear friends,

I think the problem of evolution vs creationism is beeing bigger because we
are mixing two very different ways. One we can scientifically study and
another we can not scientifically study.

The evolution of life is possible to study and putting arguments on the
table. Evolution in different ways, no problem, include creationism. If you
can prove it, there is no problem for me. If you want discuss it, no
problem. If it's dogmatic it is no more scientific...

The second thing we mixed in is is god exists or not ? I do not know.
Anyway with creationism god makes it all in 6 days. With evolution, two
ways, there is no god or there is a god and he create something which was
at the beginning and then there is evolution which changes little by little
the things. I think that with studying evolution you can try to solve the
scientific part but can not answrer to the second part "from where are we
coming". As something we can not solve, perhaps it would be better to
center the discussion to find how to convince the autorithies the evolution
exist; and including it is not in opposition with existence of god.


Jean-Michel Maes.

At 01:39 PM 11/10/99 PDT, you wrote:
>I have been a member of this listserv for about 18 months and I have never
>had a reason to post before now. As a student of chemistry and engineering
>(as well as possessing a deep love of nature and taxonomy), I have enjoyed
>this forum tremendously. I am, however, dismayed at this recent creationism
>vs. evolution banter.
>As a student. I wish only to deal with FACTS. My first organic chemistry
>professor was a soft-spoken man that shared with his class his deep respect
>for the perfect order of all living things. In my own life, I have found
>that this perfect order, the unviolatable principles upon which life is
>founded, has been the catalyst for my belief in God. Even chaos itself has
>order when expressed mathematically.
>I am concerned that there are so few of you out there--this generation's
>teachers and mentors--that find the existence of God to be so threatening to
>the classroom. I do not think that all medical reasearch and your precious
>grant money would come to a screaching halt if God turns out to be a
>You are all deeply intelligent men, scientific to the core, and I have a
>great respect for the scientific method and its approach to discerning the
>world in which we live. But, I find it distracting that there are professors
>that find it necessary to refer to a potential deity as a "malicious
>creator" and a "myth." These sentiments do not embrace open-minded,
>scientific processes of thought. These sentiments will show your classes
>that you are just as narrow-minded as the clergy that you ridicule.
>I hope that there is still room in our society for the unexplained and the
>undiscovered. I hope that miracles can happen, and while I believe science
>can solve many of the looming disasters of our time, I also believe that it
>will only accomplish the impossible if it leaves room for the impossible. No
>one knows how everything began. Yes, we are getting really good at seeing
>how it evolves, how it changes over time, but the origin of our wonderful
>little predicament may never be known. I hope that you will be able to deal
>with that knowledge professionally.
>...and, I will keep you in my prayers.
>Jeff Shaw
>Lower Columbia College
>Longview, WA 98632
>Get Your Private, Free Email at
Jean-Michel MAES
Museo Entomologico
Asociacion Nicaraguense de Entomologia
AP 527 - Leon

tel 505-0-3116586

FAX 505-0-3115700

jmmaes at


More information about the Taxacom mailing list