[Taxacom] Cavalier-Smith, 2010 on the Three Domains, paraphyly, etc.
kennethkinman at webtv.net
Sun Feb 12 21:27:44 CST 2012
I was just reading a relatively recent paper by Cavalier-Smith
(2010). He argues (more eloquently than I ever could) against the
excessive dogmatism of Hennig (and by extension his followers, who I
call "strict cladists"). He also criticizes Woese et al. in a section
called "The three-domain view of life is flawed".
It is excellent reading (a weblink to the paper is given below).
I should also note that a paper which he published in 2006 has
considerably expanded his Phylum Eurybacteria (originally proposed in
1998 for a smaller grouping), so much so that it is now almost as
inclusive as what I have always labelled as "Paraposibacteria".
Whatever you want to call the taxon, he clearly regards it (as I do) as
transitional between diderms and monoderms. He also argues quite
convincingly that the transition was from diderms (Negibacteria) to more
derived monoderms (Unibacteria, including Archaebacteria), not the other
More information about the Taxacom